Cheap with Outdoor Space (Link here)

5 bedrooms (12 beds), 3 bathrooms

$3,672 (Total of $262 each for 14 guys, $306 each for 12 guys)

Pros: Inexpensive; outdoor space to throw frisbee

Cons: Smaller; 4 beds in loft above living room

Built into the Mountain (Link here)

5 bedrooms (12 beds), 3 bathrooms

$4002 total (Total of $285 each for 14, $333 each for 12)

Pros: Inexpensive; interesting location; big porch; game room

Cons: No outdoor space; 8 beds in one room

Large and Private (Link here)

6 bedrooms (13 beds), 3 bathrooms

$4106 total (Total of $293 each for 14, $342 each for 12)

Pros: Large porch; outdoor space; large dinner table; game room; nearby private lake for fishing (release)

Cons: Lots of bunk beds; yard is hilly

Little Bit of Everything (Link here)

5 bedrooms (16 beds), 3 bathrooms

$4489 total (Total of $320 each for 14, $374 each for 12)

Pros: Plenty of beds; close to main road and Columbus; big porch; maybe a yard?

Cons: Far from Hocking Hills

Beautiful but… Neighbors? (Link here)

6 bedrooms (13 beds), 4 bathrooms

$4660 total (Total of $332 each for 14, $388 each for 12)

Pros: Lots of space; big porch; pond (possibly shared?); newer build

Cons: Little expensive; north of Hocking Hills (closer to Columbus)

Pay More, Get More (Link here)

5 bedrooms (12 beds), 3 bathrooms

$5173 total (Total of $369 each for 14, $423 each for 12)

Pros: Pool; large deck/patio; outdoor space, game room; beanbag theatre

Cons: $$, southeast of Hocking Hills (further from Columbus)

Money? Fuck Money (Link here)

6 bedrooms (13 beds), 3 bathrooms

$6228 total (Total of $444 each for 14, $519 each for 12)

Pros: large porch/patio; half basketball court; movie theatre; game room

Cons: $$$

No, Seriously, Fuck Money (Link here) 

6 bedrooms (14 beds), 3 bathrooms

$6562 total (Total of $468 each for 14, $546 each for 12)

Pros: Close to Old Man's Cave (whatever that is); INDOOR MOTHERFUCKING POOL, BITCHES!

Cons: $$$